I get really fed up with religious people telling us that the reasons for the ills in today's society are due to our rejection of religion. See today's moan by Cardinal Cormac Murphy O'Connor for example.
The UK is certainly less religious than it used to be, say 50 years ago, and our society is probably worse now than it was then. The problems in the US are a lot worse when you look at measures such as murder, teen pregnancies and drug addiction. Is the US less religious than it used to be? I don't know.
It's interesting that there are studies like those of Gregory Paul that show there is a correlation between sociological problems and religiousness and there is also the work of Phil Zuckerman who has shown that the most stable, balanced, safe, societies are the most secular, non-religious ones such as the Scandinavian countries.
Here's my take on this issue. Societies that have historically had their morality imposed on them from religious authorities have never been forced to think for themselves. It's the equivalent of a parent telling a child to do something 'because I say so'. Once that religious authority loses its influence, then there could well be a loss of moral direction, in the same way as a child might misbehave once a parent loses control.
In a society where morality isn't imposed and could be said to be somewhat subjective, you have to consider for yourself what the consequences of your actions are and take full responsibility for your actions. This internally generated morality will always stay with you.
A very interesting hypothesis.
ReplyDeleteI've read a great deal of tripe on the subject lately, and most of the rants from the religious side say we're less religious, therefore less moral therefore we have more crime... but they fail to cite any kind of study that backs up their private little hypothesis.
ReplyDeleteI like the parent-child analogy by the way.
I don't know how you would go about testing the hypothesis that less religion = more crime. Maybe it's the other way around - perhaps people become less religious when they see society failing.
ReplyDeleteAn interesting counter to the claim that lack of religion means lack of morals means more criminal behaviour is what you find from the prison population. A recent study I saw showed that the percentage of the US that identifies itself as atheist/agnostic is somewhere around 10-15% depending on which survey you read, but the equivalent percentage of the prison population was only 0.2%...